Yahoo email: how make reply to reply to email from disposable email address default to disposable

If I send an email to someone using a yahoo email 'disposable' (alias) address, and they reply, and I reply to their reply, I'd like to have my 'from' address in my reply default to the original disposable address in the thread, rather than accidentally have my real address put into my reply to their reply. I know I can search through all my disposable addresses to select the appropriate one, but I too often hit the 'send' button before I remember to select the proper disposable email address from a long list, so I'd rather that when I reply to a message in a thread, the original disposable email address that I used in the thread would be auto-selected as a default for 'from'. Is there any way this can be set to occur?